One of the components of IDEA is to provide early intervention services to those with a disability. So if we're asking the question, can a child be "too bad for FAPE? The next question to ask is did we provide interventions necessary to rehabilitate or reduce those bad behaviors? I think another part of this topic revolves around the subjectivity in the term "too bad", as most people's morality is based upon a variety of factors. How many offenses does it take for a child to be bad? Does having 10 non-violent offenses count as too bad? Or does one major violent crime constitute "too bad"? It is easy to see that arguments can be made for either or and I believe people will have a hard time choosing. Ultimately, I would not be able to agree that a child is "too bad" for FAPE considering that they are still growing and learning from their mistakes and life choices. I don't think anyone of us would like to be punished for the rest of our lives based on decisions made when we were 13 or 15 years old.
This Special Education Law Blog is intended for educational purposes only. Nothing said in the posts, comments or elsewhere in this blog should be construed as legal advice. If you have a dispute or any other legal problem, you should confer with an attorney who is licensed to practice law in your state. Any reference or description of individuals that resembles actual persons or any reference to what appears to be personally identifiable information is purely coincidental and unintentional. All comments, posts or other discussion should be accepted in the spirit of philosophical debate rather than as instruction or advice of any kind. Any abusive, profane, offensive or defamatory language of any kind is strictly prohibited and will not be tolerated. Disclosure Policy(FTC) (effective 05/23/2014) This blog is a personal and business blog written and edited by Jim Gerl. For questions about this blog, please contact jimgerl@gmail.com. Since January 1, 2017, this blog accepts paid advertising, sponsorship and/or paid insertions. I write for my own purposes and also for exposure of my business. However, it is possible that I may be influenced by my background, occupation, religion, political affiliation or experience.Since January 1, 2017, the owner of this blog receives compensation from advertisers. This blog may contain content which could present a conflict of interest; such content will be identified in the post in which it occurs.
One of the components of IDEA is to provide early intervention services to those with a disability. So if we're asking the question, can a child be "too bad for FAPE? The next question to ask is did we provide interventions necessary to rehabilitate or reduce those bad behaviors? I think another part of this topic revolves around the subjectivity in the term "too bad", as most people's morality is based upon a variety of factors. How many offenses does it take for a child to be bad? Does having 10 non-violent offenses count as too bad? Or does one major violent crime constitute "too bad"? It is easy to see that arguments can be made for either or and I believe people will have a hard time choosing. Ultimately, I would not be able to agree that a child is "too bad" for FAPE considering that they are still growing and learning from their mistakes and life choices. I don't think anyone of us would like to be punished for the rest of our lives based on decisions made when we were 13 or 15 years old.
ReplyDeleteAnon,
DeleteThanks for your comment.
JG